Holding a Book Bound in Human Skin

B3It is hot and muggy in the upstairs gallery of Surgeons’ Hall in Edinburgh. I walk past shelves upon shelves of jars that contain 18th-century specimens suspended in liquid: an amputated arm here, a cancerous bowel there. Compared with the lower level of the museum, it is eerily quiet up here. This section is not open to the public and so these objects are rarely gazed upon with such naked curiosity as I am experiencing now.

In this instance, I am not Dr Lindsey Fitzharris, medical historian. I am as inquisitive as any person who would be granted access to the collection up here, bubbling over with questions and observations about the bits of body parts floating before my eyes. But before I can seek answers to these questions, I must first view the object I’ve come to write about: a pocketbook bound in the skin of the 19th-century murderer, William Burke.

B2I make my way to the end of the gallery where the Director of Heritage, Chris Henry, is standing in the corner. In his gloved hand, he holds the notorious pocketbook which has attracted tourists from around the world to Surgeons’ Hall for decades. I have never seen it outside of a glass case. It looks less ‘sacred’ without the dim spotlights and laminated cards describing its origins.

It looks almost normal.

But of course, it isn’t normal. Far from it. In 1828, William Burke and William Hare murdered 16 people over the course of 10 months. Masquerading as bodysnatchers, the two murderers then sold the fresh corpses onto surgeons in Edinburgh where the bodies were then dissected in private anatomy schools dotted around the city.

Burke and Hare were eventually apprehended when one of their victims was discovered in the dissection room of Dr Robert Knox, who had been purchasing many of the suspiciously fresh bodies from the two men over the past several months. Hare turned King’s evidence and was released, while Burke took the blame and was sentenced to death. What awaited him at the end of the rope was much worse than even he could imagine.

B6

Chris hands me a pair of white gloves. He’s an expert on this object, so the interview flows easily. He regales me with stories about how it came into existence, telling me that Burke’s body was privately dissected as a mob of several hundred people gathered outside the surgeons’ window demanding to be let in.

As Chris speaks, it suddenly happens. He hands me the pocketbook, almost as if he is handing me any book from a library shelf. I can’t feel it in the same way I would if I wasn’t wearing gloves, but I have a visceral reaction to the object nonetheless. This is the actual skin of a notorious murderer–a man I had been reading about for years in my own research.

Burke1This is the closest I will ever get to Burke’s physical self. It’s as if I’ve reached out and touched his arm, which of course I just may have given the material this object is made from.

After my initial reaction, I begin inspecting the pocketbook more carefully. It is remarkably well preserved considering this was meant to be a functioning item. Indeed, the original pencil that came with the pocketbook is still tucked neatly inside its covers. Looking at it, I can hardly believe someone would use it to carry money. Even for me–the Queen of Macabre–this is all a bit too much.

Its covers are soft and pliable after all these years, reminding me that this was indeed used on a regular basis. In faded gold letters, the front reads: BURKE’S SKIN POCKET BOOK. When I turn it over in my hands, the words–EXECUTED 28 JAN 1829–complete the story.

B5Emma Black, who heads public engagement at the museum, talks to me after the interview. As with any museum containing human specimens, Surgeons’ Hall has several pieces on display that are controversial. Interestingly, Burke’s skin book isn’t often mentioned as one of them. She wonders if, given the atrocity of the crimes committed, some of us have come to accept that this object is suitable for display. At the time, the dissection and book acted as a further punishment for Burke’s crimes and was seen as a form of justice which fitted the horrific nature of the murders themselves. Burke’s skeleton is also on display at the University of Edinburgh’s Anatomical Museum (right).

For me, however, the pocketbook is much more than this. It represents the growing need for bodies in the dissection room at the beginning of the 19th century, and the willingness by some anatomists to turn a blind eye to the dubious doings of those who procured the dead on their behalf.

In short, the pocketbook represents a dark and sordid part of our medical history.

After several minutes, I hand the pocketbook back to Emma. Once more back in its case, the object takes on that ‘sacred’ glow.

If you enjoy reading my articles, please consider becoming a patron of The Chirurgeon’s Apprentice. Support my content by clicking HERE.

*Please note that Surgeons’ Hall Museum is closed for redevelopment and will reopen in Summer 2015. 

By | 2014-11-26T13:21:46+00:00 November 26th, 2014|Casebooks|10 Comments

10 Comments

  1. coldhandboyack November 26, 2014 at 2:15 pm - Reply

    That’s awesome. I believe there was a wild west outlaw who became a pair of shoes. Thanks for sharing this with us.

  2. Shruti November 26, 2014 at 2:22 pm - Reply

    Okay. I don’t know if you are a follower of grey’s anatomy. The famous medicine series, but there was a cardiac surgeon in it whose name was apparently (ahem!) William Burke. Now I am awed why would they choose this name in particular. May be its just a co incidence or maybe even shonda rhimes was fascinated by medical history. 😉

  3. Tom Baird November 26, 2014 at 4:16 pm - Reply

    And, I fancy myself sitting with Burke & Hare in a pub when they ask, “What do you think of our plan?”, to which I reply, “I’ll wait for the movie”.

  4. […] The Chirurgeon’s Apprentice: Holding a Book Bound in Human Skin […]

  5. herschelian December 4, 2014 at 9:45 am - Reply

    Co-incidence is a strange thing – I first read about Burke and Hare in my late teens, but hadn’t thought of them for over thirty plus years until last week when I blogged about the spate of bodysnatching that is going on in China at the moment.
    https://herschelian.wordpress.com/2014/11/23/bodysnatchers-in-china/
    Whilst looking up what happened to B&H as I was writing it I read about B’s skin being made into a pocket book. Then I open your blog post and there it is.
    Did they dye the skin, or was it the tanning process which darkened it? It is horridly fascinating. I do remember reading, once again many years ago, a book about the atrocities committed by some of the Nazi concentration camp staff, and seeing a picture of what purported to be a lamp-shade made of human skin. Could my memory be correct?

  6. […] here’s a more recent post on a pocket book covered in the nineteenth-century body snatcher William Burke’s skin by […]

  7. Thank you, I have just been searching for info about this subject for a while and
    yours is the greatest I have discovered so far.

    But, what concerning the conclusion? Are you sure in regards to the
    supply?

  8. […] here’s a more recent post on a pocket book covered in the nineteenth-century body snatcher William Burke’s skin by […]

  9. Ivan February 23, 2015 at 12:28 pm - Reply

    Just so you know, the link to your personal page is broken. It should, of course, be http://www.drlindseyfitzharris.com/ but you have linked it as http://thechirurgeonsapprentice.com/2014/11/26/holding-a-book-bound-in-human-skin/www.drlindseyfitzharris.com

  10. […] « Holding a book bound in human skin » sur le site de The chirurgeon’s apprentice […]

Leave A Comment